Home / Featured, People Management / Effective strategies for coaching and developing your employees

Effective strategies for coaching and developing your employees

Performance coaching is not about disciplinary action, nor is it about accountability (although it may promote accountability in the long term). It is really about leadership development - teaching your team of supervisors, managers and leaders the skills and behaviors that are necessary to perform their jobs as efficiently as possible in order to get the best results for themselves and the company.

Performance coaching is not about telling your management team what to do; it is about telling them how to get the best results from their people and processes. If you are experiencing mediocre productivity, ongoing conflict or high turnover, you should look first at your management team. They are the root cause for success and failure. There is an old Chinese proverb that says, “For every hundred men hacking away at the branches of a diseased tree, only one will stoop to inspect the roots.”

It is surprising to me the number of managers and executives that I meet who have no idea how to conduct performance coaching sessions. While facilitating an executive coaching session with a vice president, she told me that she had continually written her managers up and they continued to deliver substandard performance! Her frustration was evident, but writing people up is self-defeating when you have not performed due diligence in the supervisor’s or manager’s performance training. It does not teach the employee or manager the skills they need to move forward. It only punishes them for making mistakes and not performing up to expected standards.

The fact is that most supervisors and managers want to do a good job, but many do not have the skills to deal with the complicated workforce issues prevalent in today’s organizations. Many supervisors and managers are learning as they go. This process is slow, ineffective and costly to organizations as supervisors and managers bungle their way through each day, trying to do the right things.

To effectively conduct performance coaching sessions, you must first understand the root cause of poor performance. Performance is a function of both ability and motivation. For example, someone with 100 percent motivation and 75 percent ability can achieve good to above average performance. However, someone with 25 percent ability will most likely not be able to perform to expected standards, no matter how highly motivated they are to succeed. In the latter case, you will have to identify a strategic plan to provide this person with the skills they need to succeed or you may have to assess whether they are in the right position. Key signs that low ability may be the root cause of poor performance are:

• Evidence of strong effort despite poor performance
• Lack of improvement over time despite ongoing coaching and training

Performance Coaching for Management Development

Coaching to develop your management team allows leaders to leverage the organization’s human capital, creating competitive advantage. Supervisors and managers have a direct impact on how employees feel about working for the organization.

“Once the economy turns around, disgruntled employees will certainly begin to consider a job change,” said Lori Dernavich, a business advisor on workplace performance solutions and founder of Lori Dernavich LLC.

Coaching and counseling for management development ranges from helping poor performers improve to capitalizing on high-potential supervisors and managers by keeping them challenged and encouraging them to continuously improve their skills.

Coaching is not a one-way street. Both the leader and the supervisor or manager shares the responsibility for positive results. Highly effective performance coaches share the following characteristics:

• Base the coaching relationship on trust
• Are optimists about human nature
• Give people opportunities to take risks and learn from their mistakes
• Practice effective listening skills
• Speak candidly
• Encourage personal accountability and ownership
• Know their strengths and weaknesses and continually strive to leverage strengths and overcome weaknesses
• Are continuous learners

Performance Coaching Strategies and Tactics

Below are three key strategies for effective performance coaching. They include:

Strategy 1 - Create a culture of involvement and ownership

Tactics:

1. Provide the knowledge, skills, tools, resources and education to ensure supervisor’s or manager’s success
2. Share the vision, mission and business objectives, ensuring that they understand where they fit in to the big picture
3. Set clear standards for results and behaviors
4. Reward and recognize results and behaviors

Strategy 2 - Provide challenging assignments

Tactics:

1. Assess the supervisor’s or manager’s abilities
2. Make assignments that align with their abilities
3. Provide clear direction and expectations
4. Remove roadblocks and barriers
5. Trust them to accomplish the task
6. Reward and recognize effort and results

Strategy 3 - Provide ongoing coaching

Tactics:

1. Provide constructive criticism. Meet monthly to discuss the supervisor’s or manager’s progress and areas where improvement is needed
2. Document the monthly conversations
3. Remove barriers and roadblocks
4. Provide tools and resources
5. Use effective listening and feedback skills

Coaches as Mentors

I am frequently asked about the difference between coaches and mentors. It is true that great coaches often become dedicated mentors. The definition of a mentor is: “A person who gives another person the benefit of his or her years of experience and/or education. This is experience that is shared in such a way that the mentor helps to develop a mentee’s skills and abilities, benefiting the mentee and the organization.” However, there are clear differences between a coach and a mentor. Below is a quick guide to mentoring for improved performance.

Why Mentoring is Different than Coaching

As I said, coaching is not the same as mentoring. Mentoring is concerned with the development of the whole person and driven by the person’s own work/life goals. It is usually unstructured and informal. Coaching is much more about achieving specific objectives in a particular way. Coaching is also more formal and more structured, usually around a coaching process or methodology.

In other words, mentoring is less skill-based and more of a relationship-based process. A good mentoring relationship is identified by the willingness and capability of both parties to ask questions, challenge assumptions and disagree.

The mentor is far less likely to have a direct-line relationship with the mentee, and in a mentoring relationship, this distance is desirable. Mentoring is rarely a critical part of an individual’s job role but rather an extra element that rewards the mentor with fresh thinking as well as the opportunity to transfer knowledge and experience to a less experienced colleague, peer or employee. If you are interested in becoming a mentor, the following tips may prove useful.

Tips for Effective Mentoring:

• The mentee has no direct-line reporting to the mentor. This fosters trust and the mentee feels more comfortable in sharing uncertainties about his or her abilities, creating free-flowing, open communication.
• The mentor/mentee relationship is mutually satisfying. The mentor gets the satisfaction of watching someone grow as a result of his or her insights. The mentee gains a feeling of being valued, receiving beneficial direction and attention from someone who they respect and admire.
• The intensity of the relationship is matched. It is taking up actual and mental time in proportions with which both people are comfortable. This time commitment is flexible as the mentee’s needs change (e.g. there may be several meetings in a short period of time during a very challenging period, then none for months).
• At any time, either party can stop the relationship and the mentoring process. There is no obligation for continuance.
• The mentee is not a protégé. It is not a teacher-pupil relationship, nor does the mentee (necessarily) have the patronage of the mentor.
•  An effective mentor gives wise counsel, and the mentee feels comfortable speaking on issues that may be sensitive. Once this trust is developed, the mentor can give advice or assist with tough recommendations.
• The mentor is not mentoring two people at the same time who have a close working relationship. Discretion and confidentiality are paramount. The rules of engagement are stated up front with an agreement between the mentor and the mentee on who should be aware of the mentoring relationship.
• The obligation for continuing is two-sided. When the mentor feels they have value to add and the mentee is getting something from the relationship, the mentoring may go on indefinitely or either side can end it without justification.
• Mentoring programs are about guidance and facilitation rather than formal training.

Becoming a mentor is a personal choice. Learning to effectively provide performance coaching is a necessary skill for retaining top talent within the management and front-line employee ranks. It is critical that leadership within organizations do everything in their power to give management the skills they need to successfully get results through people and processes.

Please respond to this blog entry with your questions, comments, suggestions and stories of effective and non-effective coaching, development and mentoring.

Related posts:

1. The art of managing layoffs: What to do when cuts are unavoidable Prior to layoffs, you must maintain lines of open communication...
2. Help employees get the most out of their career, their life “Rex, your maintenance leadership mentoring program caused four employees to...
3. How to hire right-fit employees In this article, we will discuss the second step in...
4. Manufacturing improvement and the Rolling Stones If you’re like me, you’ve listened to the Rolling Stones...
5. Workforce retention: How do you keep your best employees? In my first two blog columns for Reliable Plant, we...

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment and subscribing to the email alerts or RSS feed.

Filed Under: Featured, People Management    |  Tags: business management, change management, maintenance management, management, People Management

Comments

Trackbacks

• Reliable Plant Magazine: Effective Strategies for Coaching and Developing your Employees : Welcome to The Coaching Commons
• Effective strategies for coaching and developing your employees